Headcanons and what Nie Huaisang did or did not do
Aug. 18th, 2025 03:05 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
An idea someone had in the cx server: NHS realizes the soul switching array didn’t work, WWX is already in someone else’s body and so must figure it out. Fun enough, but it ultimately doesn’t work for me because it underscores why I don’t think it makes sense for NHS to be behind MXY doing that: WWX being at Mo manor is unnecessary for his plan to be put into effect. All he needs is LWJ, and involving the Lan juniors ropes him in.
Wei Wuxian is actually a potential complication, if you think about it. He's a wildcard. Can Nie Huaisang really anticipate, much less control what he will do? Adding to that, well, why would Nie Huaisang think putting Lan Wangji and Wei Wuxian together in this situation lead to something better and more productive than just Lan Wangji? He would not assume they'd collaborate and work well together. As far as he knows, they were constantly at odds (of course this is different in CQL, but I am not a CQL girlie, I am always will be going from novel canon). This is actually potentially bad if the goal is to the truth about Dage's death come to light and especially, to make sure cultivation society believes this. Lan Wangji has the reputation to be believed. Wei Wuxian... not so much, not necessarily.
So personally I think Nie Huaisang’s plan as presented through Wei Wuxian’s deductions at the end is unnecessarily complicated and doesn’t make sense, which is why this is one aspect of mdzs where I just ignore probable authorial intent… at least I assume mxtx does probably intend for his deductions to be true, even if it’s not actually verified within the story. It's just Wei Wuxian's suppositions, really. So I can and will do what I like with my headcanons.
Does this mean I think Nie Huaisang is an innocent little lamb? No. I just don’t think he did everything Wei Wuxian thinks he did. Because it just does not make sense to me.
Some of it (luring the juniors to Yi City) makes more sense if mxtx had gone ahead with her original idea to give him an accomplice. But that’s not what she wrote, so that leaves me, again, to find an interpretation that makes sense to me given what we DO know in canon.